@القيصر الروماني
هل شاهدت هذه الدراما من عام 2005 , إن كنت محب لروما و لا تعرفها فقد فاتك نصف عمرك.
رايتها ولا تمت لصلة بالواقع التاريخي حالها حال جميع افلام هوليود وافلام peplum التي تناولت الحقبة اليونانية والرومانية .لذا بتباتا لا ينصح بها من حيث اعتبارها مادة تاريخية والاسوء منها مسلسل
Spartacus: Blood and Sand فيلم دعارة وتخيلي بامتياز ولا يمت لتاريخ الروماني باي صلة
وهذا نقد ذاتي لمنتج مسلسل روما وتحريفاته التاريخية
There are numerous inaccuracies in the series' representation of various historical events and personages. Co-creator
Bruno Heller has said: "We try to balance between what people expect from previous portrayals and a naturalistic approach ... This series is much more about how the psychology of the characters affects history than simply following the history as we know it".
[62] Series Historical Consultant Jonathan Stamp also notes that the show aims for "authenticity" rather than "accuracy".
[5][63][64] The filmmakers stressed that they wanted to portray a more accurate picture of Rome, a gritty and realistic city as opposed to what they call the "Hollyrome" presentation that audiences are used to from other films, with "cleanliness and marble and togas that looked pressed."
[65]
We did everything we could to make these episodes historically authentic, which meant researching and incorporating every kind of detail we could about the way our characters behaved, the way they interacted, how they dressed and gestured, the kind of streets they walked down, the way they conducted their private and public lives. We were not, however, making a documentary. We were striving for authenticity because it enriches the experience of the drama for the viewer. — Jonathan Stamp
[5]
Lucius Vorenus and
Titus Pullo are historical figures mentioned briefly in Caesar's
Commentarii de Bello Gallico, but their adventures and involvement in key events in the series are fictional.
[5][63] Some important events are not mentioned in
Rome, including the whole year spent before the
Battle of Dyrrhachium, which, though indecisive, was considered a victory for Pompeius. Many significant members of the
Optimates, the traditionalist faction of
Brutus and
Cato, are also missing from the series. They include
Titus Labienus,
Lucius Domitius Ahenobarbus,
Lucius Cornelius Lentulus Crus, and
Publius Cornelius Lentulus Spinther, who failed to empty Rome's treasury before the
Optimates' departure, resulting in a severe lack of funds to support their war effort
وهنا كمثال نقد للتحريفات التاريخية لفيلم gladiator والاهم ان جميع الافلام التي انتجت وتناولت الرومان لا علاقة لها بالحقائق التاريخية .
https://www.historyhit.com/historical-inaccuracies-from-the-film-gladiator/